Folk who speak stammeringly also listen and as listeners we need some attention too.
When someone is speaking to me:
I need him to speak in short simple sentences that I can relate to easily. Out with longwinded complicated sentences with lots of subclauses. It is hard enough in print but very difficult to keep up with in speech. Simple past present and future tenses will do nicely.
I need him to speak at a rate that allows me to put my thoughts about what he is saying in some sort of context. When people are nervous they often speak too fast.
I need a little thinking time between sentences.
I need to hear clearly what the person is saying and for him not to mumble. Most people mumble when they are not sure of themselves.
I need to see the speaker’s mouth moving. We lip read more than we think. I also need him to keep his hands, cup or drinking glass away from his mouth. We tend to cover our mouths when we are nervous.
I need him to face me, otherwise I can’t hear him and may be unaware that he is speaking to me.
I need him to articulate as clearly as they can manage so that I can distinguish words and sentences.
Now, I know that someone stammering might be doing all of the above and, if that is so, I will be able to make out what he is saying. I won’t have to feel I need to ask for a repeat: ‘Sorry. I didn’t catch that?’
Don’t take my word for it. Ask yourself what you need as a listener. Use the news or interviews to investigate what you need: not what they are giving you – not the content but the delivery. Good newsreaders will be trained to think in terms of the audience’s needs and to find ways to meet them.
When I am trying to listen to what someone is saying and he mumbles, the first thing I think is that I have missed something. I want to hear him and I can’t. I am confused: and being confused feels very uncomfortable.
Deep or quiet voices can be particularly difficult for me to make out.
Now, I know that real people, rather than actors, don’t choose to stammer but we are all listeners and although PWS will know the difficulties of speaking, as listeners they can appreciate the hearer’s needs too.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
I'm afraid I'm not sure I understand what you're wanting stutterers to do.
One of the first thoughts that comes into my mind when I stutter is, "How awful it must be for my listener to have to listen to me sound like this."
I probably obsess about my listener's needs too much, as I suspect many other stutterers do too.
And if I could do all the things you ask of your listener, believe me I would. I would love to be able to talk in short simple sentences (the way I talk inside my head) and to articulate more clearly. But for me, as a stutterer, it's not as simple as just deciding to do that.
My apologies if I've misinterpreted your post.
Best wishes,
Sophie
Hi Sophie
I don't want PWS to do anything but I thought it would be worth clarifying what the listener needs: me, for example.
I take your point about being concerned for your listener and thinking it is awful for them to listen to you. Is this black and white type thinking?
It might be a small challenge for them to make sense but 'awful' is a bit extreme. 'Now, this might be a small challenge for them but it will pay them to stick with it', might be more 'both/and'.
Transmitting the sense that we want to make when speaking to someone is the issue for me. And what I wanted to consider were some of the other things we can attend to that help listeners to receive the sense that someone wants to transmit - not just the articulation of the words or the sound produced.
As I write I am reminded that we use gestures a lot to help the transmission of the sense - just look at folk using mobile phones oblivious to others around them.
Attending to small things that one believes can help things along is better than attending to what hasn't worked, I think.
Analogue approach - eat the elephant one bite at a time, and little by little merge into how you want to deliver your meaning. Pick one easy thing and see how it goes for a week, then add another and so on.
It might not help, but if it opens ones thinking up it can't be bad.
Like with the posts; one bit at a time. In fact I worry that I put too much into each of the posts.
Hope this helps
Peter
It does help. Thank you.
Sophie
Post a Comment